Why do people keep drinking this poison?

August 10, 2026

forgiveness

Bitterness is such a strange companion, isn’t it?

Often dressed as righteousness it tells us we have every reason to feel wounded, betrayed, overlooked, or wronged. And sure, sometimes, we do.

Life can be breathtakingly unfair. People can be careless with our hearts. Trust can be broken. Losses can arrive without apology. That’s real hurt.

But what I’ll never understand is those who decide to build a home inside that hurt and live in it.

The grudge

At first, holding a grudge can feel protective. I’ve been there and so have you: replaying the offense, rehearsing our case before friends and family (or even in our minds, before an imaginary jury). We show the evidence. We revisit old conversations. We polish our grievances to a glistening shine.

The problem?  The person we’re punishing is often not the one suffering.  Bitterness asks for rent, and it collects that rent from us, not the other. We’re the one that’s suffering.

I think of that old saying “Withholding forgiveness is like drinking poison and expecting the other person to die.”

It  may not be immediately apparent, but bitterness steals joy from our lives. It clouds potentially beautiful moments. It makes us suspicious of kindness and wary of new beginnings. It colors the world in darker shades than it deserves.

The clouded lens

Over time, a grudge becomes a lens through which everything is viewed.

The friend who forgot.
The sibling who disappointed us.
The partner who failed us.
The boss who overlooked us.

As we replay it in our mind, the offense grows larger in memory than it was in life. We become custodians of old pain, tending it carefully, feeding it attention, keeping it alive long after the original wound should have begun to heal.

It’s toxic.

But life is going on

Meanwhile…

Spring unfolds its blossoms. Summer hums with life. Autumn scatters its gold across the ground. Winter wraps the world in stillness. The years pass. Hair turns silver. Faces soften. People leave us. Opportunities disappear.

And still we clutch the old grievance as though it were treasure.

What a heartbreaking bargain.

Because bitterness does nothing but poison the present.

I’ve known people who have carried grudges for decades. (I’m Sicilian, so of course I do.)

The original injury had long since faded from everyone else’s memory, but they carry it like a sacred relic. Their stories never change. The names remain the same. The wounds remain fresh because they are reopened constantly, implicitly or explicitly.

The tragedy

But. The real tragedy wasn’t what had happened to them.

The tragedy is what they missed while looking backward.

The laughter they didn’t hear.
The love they couldn’t fully receive.
The peace that stood patiently at the door but was never invited in.

Forgiveness is one of life’s most important lessons

Thankfully, I am not a grudge-holder. It’s not that I haven’t been done wrong. It’s just that I learned to develop perspective on those wrongs. And here’s what else I learned:

Forgiveness does not mean approving of what happened. It does not require reconciliation. It does not erase accountability.

Forgiveness is simply choosing freedom over being right.  Setting down a burden that has grown too heavy to carry.

As we age, this becomes one of life’s most important lessons. We realize that our days are finite. We realize that resentment is far too expensive and life far too precious.

The people who age most gracefully are often the ones who have learned to release what no longer serves them. To trust that healing is not forgetting, but remembering without bleeding.

There is enough sorrow in life without manufacturing more of it. There are enough losses without choosing to relive the old ones every morning.

If bitterness is a poison, forgiveness is not a gift we give someone else.

It is the antidote we give ourselves.

And perhaps the greatest act of courage is not holding on. It is opening our hand and our heart in forgiveness.

24 comments on “Why do people keep drinking this poison?
  1. Gretchen Sand says:

    well said Carol!

  2. Ambuj Saxena says:

    We all hold grudges but after reading your blog post, I go back to the days when i healed myself as i had felt caged inside my grudges and bitterness. Earlier, my ego and my grudges used to create a cloud of fear and aloofness but now i have started to see beyond it. Though I am still a Work in progress

  3. Beth Havey says:

    Ah so important. None of us is perfect. Some of us hurt others when we really do not realize that we did. Marriages fall apart when forgiveness is not part of the vow. And YES, we take those vows to honor, love and sometimes even obey…and what should be added: FORGIVE. It takes strength to hurt someone. It takes even more strength to FORGIVE or even explain to that person, WHY YOU HURT THEM.

  4. Amber Myers says:

    I will hold onto some things. I try to let most go, but if I’ve been severely wronged, I will drop that person like a bad habit, and I will hope Karma comes and bites them on the ass.

    But if it’s small slights, I can move on.

  5. There are so many lines in here I could hang on my wall… One of my favorites: Bitterness asks for rent, and it collects that rent from us, not the other.

  6. Beth Havey says:

    Forgiveness is golden. You cannot put a price on it.

  7. Laurie Stone says:

    I love Mel Robbin’s phrase, “Let them.” Its very simple but puts everything into place for me. We spend so much energy trying to change others, when we really can’t. Let them do their thing and let us free ourselves from needing to alter them.

  8. jerry says:

    I really connected with your reflection on forgiveness. The idea of choosing freedom over being right is powerful, especially the reminder that releasing bitterness allows us to fully embrace the life happening around us.

  9. Beth says:

    So many people think forgiveness equals someone “getting away with it”. Forgiveness is for YOU. Not the other person.

  10. LisaLisa says:

    This was such a powerful read. Bitterness really does have a way of stealing our peace while the person who hurt us may not even realize the pain we’re carrying. I especially loved the reminder that forgiveness isn’t about excusing what happened, but about choosing freedom for ourselves.

  11. Stephanie says:

    I definitely held on to grudges more when I was younger. But as I got older, I realized that holding grudges, as you said, is worse for me than the other person.

  12. Richard Lowe says:

    I agree that holding grudges is counter-productive. However, I’d also note it’s important to remember, without getting emotional about it, who has harmed you and, more importantly, is it a recurring pattern. This allows you to choose to keep those people in your life who are beneficial and good people. But none of this should be tainted with bitterness. as you say, that’s poison.

  13. Melanie E says:

    This post really does capture how holding onto things can quietly steal away our happiness. Your phrase “remembering without bleeding” is incredibly powerful. Choosing freedom over being right is such a necessary reminder, as holding onto bitterness only hurts us. It is important to learn forgiveness but then moving forward find ways to protect ourselves from further hurt.

  14. This really resonated with me, especially the reminder that forgiveness doesn’t mean excusing what happened—it means choosing not to let the hurt keep taking up space in our lives. Life is far too precious to spend it carrying old wounds, and there’s something incredibly freeing about finally setting that weight down.

  15. Agree, and thanks for sharing – Forgiveness as the antidote we give ourselves feels like the clearest way to put it.

  16. Elizabeth F says:

    We can forgive and never forget because our memory doesn’t just toss things out after we forgive. But I get where you are coming from.
    True, forgiveness is really for us to move on with life and not get held hostage by bad events that affected us, but it’s not always that simple for everyone. It takes time and there is no cut off date. People need the time to grieve and make peace in their hearts with what happened.
    Sadly, not everyone feels the need to do so and some people believe that certain events are unforgivable. That is life.

  17. **Comment 1:**
    That idea of bitterness quietly taking away from the life happening right in front of us really stayed with me. Forgiveness doesn’t erase what happened, but carrying the hurt forever can become its own kind of burden. Choosing peace can take a lot of courage.

  18. The reminder that forgiveness is something we give ourselves really makes sense. We can remember what happened without letting it colour every new day. Life moves so quickly, and peace feels like a much better place to put our energy.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

*

Follow Carol

Welcome!

Here you’ll find my blog, some of my essays, published writing, and my solo performances. There’s also a link to my Etsy shop for healing and grief tools offered through A Healing Spirit.

 

I love comments, so if something resonates with you in any way, don’t hesitate to leave a comment on my blog. Thank you for stopping by–oh, and why not subscribe so you don’t miss a single post?

Archives

Subscribe to my Blog

Receive notifications of my new blog posts directly to your email.